I had the opportunity to read her newest novel from the Hickory Hollow series entitled The Bridesmaid through Bethany House book reviewer program (in exchange for the book I am asked to give my unbiased review of the work).
I am usually a devout and loving fan of Lewis' work, but I was quite disappointed with this novel. The main story line is that of Joanna and her dreams of being wed, despite her 'old' age and being 3 times a bridesmaid. Reaching what seems to be the end of her courting years with now prospects in sights, a happen chance meeting on the shoreline with a boy from another state re energizes her desire for love, marriage, and an Amish family. Eben and Joanna begin a long distance courtship through letters and weekly phone calls, but many bumps hinder their plans. This is where I lost love with the novel. There were too many subplot story lines that never seemed to 1) be explained as to why they were problems in the first place (like the troubled relationship between Joanna and her younger sister) or 2) that were brought up but never really dealt with again. I felt like the entire book was a constant cycle of Joanna receiving a letter, fighting with her sister, lamenting to a wiser woman in her town, and then writing back to Eben. Chapter after chapter never really seemed to go anywhere. There were also many subplots that just hindered the telling of the story and detracted more than added value (The quilt storyline was neat and would have loved to hear more about it, but it ended up just being a distraction in my point of view).
The nature of the Hickory Hollow series is that they are supposed to be stand alone novels. Therefore, many of the storylines I felt were not wrapped up well (like Joanna's love for writing and whether it became an issue).
Overall, I love Lewis as an author and is the go to source for great Amish fiction, but I would point those seeking that genre to another one of her great series.
Here is a link to the book's trailer. http://www.youtube.com/watch?